I really enjoyed my EDTS 325 class this week. We looked
at 7 different interactive systems and how they can be used by teachers in a
classroom. It was so interesting to see all the different systems and
experiment with them, seeing how each one worked from both the view of the
creator (teacher) and the student interacting with the app. I am going to
review my findings for 3 of the different systems and examine both the pros and
the cons of each.
They will be rated as follows:
5=very effective (user-friendly,
multi-purpose)
4=mostly effective (fairly user
friendly, useful features)
3=somewhat effective
2=potentially effective, but only
with practice
1=uneffective, too
complicated/simplistic
POLLEVERYWHERE: 4.5
Teacher Use
First, I am going to look at it from
the view of the teacher creating questions.
http://www.polleverywhere.com
is a great site to use for quick polls in the classroom. Their tag line is “30 seconds to set up and
no sign in required”. They are true to
their word. I had already used it before so had created an account. The benefit of this is that all your polls
are kept under your sign in name so they are available for reuse. It is a
great tool for the classroom. They created a room with a number for me to add
my questions with multiple choice answers. Then the questions are activated and
the student is given a code to text to their phone. DONE, that easy!
Student Use
As long
as the student has access to their own cell phone it is easy, especially the
second time. The first time I used it, I
had a bit of trouble figuring out what to text just because it was so new to me
(and I am old!). It was fun to see the
answers register and the graph grow.
Flexibility
The
only drawback is that there isn’t an open ended response. Students can’t type in an answer and have it
displayed. So, it is great for a quick poll in the classroom. Flash quizzes with live instant results, what
a great way to get students attention. All free!
Diagnostic feedback
As a teacher,
you can create reports and identify which students answered what, which is good
to identify needs. You can also create anonymous
polls to protect student identity.
Plickers: 4
Teacher Use
This
was my first time on www.plickers.com . Wow, is all I can say. Wow, was I impressed
with this app. It is so exciting. You get real time answers from your students with
just the click of the camera. It reads the student’s answer card giving real
time results. It is a lot more work than
the other applications we used as you need to add your student’s names and
print out individual cards for each student.
Once you have done the initial setup, it saves your class list and you
can laminate the cards so that they can be used many times. As the teacher, I think that as you gather
the answers by scanning the room with your devices camera you have the most fun
watching the information get snatched up magically and organized for you. I think it is great for younger classrooms or
in classrooms where students don’t have access to digital devices.
Student Use
Students
get a laminated card that is made just for them with their names linked to
it. It is easy to use, they simply hold
up a card with the side with the letter that corresponds to their answer at the
top. Little kids may get confused with
putting the right answer to the top. It
isn’t really exciting for the students but I think the teacher has fun gathering
responses.
Flexibility
No open
ended response. Just good for quick
polling of predetermined answers.
Diagnosis feedback
It is a
bit limited as it only works for multiple choice questions and not open
responses by students. It shows in real time as the phone passes by the students. It shows which students you have scanned and
if you missed anyone. It is a bit cumbersome
as you have to print out cards, keep them organized and hand them out to the
students each time. I think the first
few times would be very fun but I worry because it isn’t as spontaneous, it
wouldn’t be used as much as the others.
Padlet-3
Teacher Use
I have a real mixed review of www.padlet.com . Padlet was easy to sign in and you can create
an account or just use it without creating an account. I loved that students got to fill in their
own padlet or sticky note, so it was the best application for individual unique
responses. I really disliked that it
wasn’t user friendly. I felt frustrated
trying to set it up. The question text was
too small. I wanted to be able to adjust
it and make it bigger or bolder on the screen.
I even used Google looking for ways to change it and couldn’t figure it
out. I see how it would be a great way
to get student unique responses and I am sure that I will use it in my
classroom.
Student Use
Padlet
is very easy to use. Students are logged in by room number and they double
click anywhere on the page to write their response. It is a great way to get the individual voices
heard. It can be used on a desktop or
tablet.
Flexibility
This is
a great application for individual response, although you can’t use it for
multiple choice responses.
Diagnosis feedback
It was
very difficult to figure out. Out of all
the websites I used, I spent the most time trying to figure this one out and
felt very frustrated! It offers an
option to use a background, which I was thrilled with, but when you applied the
wallpaper it repeated the picture rather than fitting to size. There was no adjustment at all. It would have been nice if you could mute it
or make the student answers more prominent.
FYI
Socrative Teacher- 5
Google
Forms- 5+
Answer
Garden- 3 (very cool but just makes word clouds with the answer so I would give
it 5 for making a classroom word clouds but 3 for effective polling)
Kahoot-
4
I only was going to review three of
the seven sites I used but I can’t stop without mentioning Socartive
Teacher/Socrative Student. Socrative is
so versatile! It was easy to set up and
I loved how you could add pictures that related to your quiz to make it more
appealing. It is great because it has
several different ways you can use it.
Space race is a quick race to see who can answer the fastest! I love competition so it is a great way to
wake up and engage your students. It
also has an exit ticket where, as a teacher, you can get a snapshot of the
students’ understanding, questions they have or what they have learned. Great way to end the class.
My other favorite is Google
forms! What an amazing site. It is so versatile and just like everything Google,
it seems perfect in every way. It has
many different ways you can ask questions from grids to multiple choice. It saves automatically and is free. Finding out about this will impact me greatly
as a teacher. I believe this is the
answer to communication with parents. No
more crumpled papers on the bottom of the back pack!
Hi Kimara,
ReplyDeleteI just wrote you a long comment that I lost!
Simplified....in Padlet the repeat image is frustrating. It has to do with the size of your image. The only fix I know is to use a larger image. For example, the chart I had on the background in class was large enough that it didn't repeat.
To make the text bigger, one trick I use is to hit control n the key board and then use the rolly dial on your mouse...the screen will zoom, making the font larger. I'll try to remember to show that in class again; remind me if you think of it.
Great work personalizing your sites.
Cammie
Thanks Cammie for the advice! I will try that next time to see if that works! I really did love all the interactive sites and think that they will be useful! Can't wait to see what other exciting things there are in the future!
DeleteHey Kimara!
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with your thought on teacher use through Padlet. I think it could be a lot better if it was more user friendly and easier to navigate around!
I also agree with thought on Plickers where you mention that it would only be fun the first few times. I never really thought about it that way but I can definitely see how that could happen... Especially having to get organized and pass out the cards all the time!
Lexci
Thanks Lexci! I am so sorry I spelled your name wrong when I commented on your blog!!
Delete